Long-time listener, first-time caller. ;)
I agree that looks matter a lot. Although personality and chemistry are huge, physical attractiveness is much more imporant for girls. Since looks matter and Tynan has made health a high priority in his life, it makes sense that he would place emphasis on it as a requirement in whomever he dates. And when you're a guy with options like Tynan, "small" things like this that other men would look past can be deal-breakers.
I too have noticed that a lot of girls go with the "good enough" approach to their body, especially in cold weather climates where their body is fully covered by clothing most of the year. Unfortunately, that probably won't land them a really high quality guy, but maybe their aren't enough really high quality guys out their for them to think it's worth the extra effort.