I'd like tynan.com to work with my Google Reader like it used to.  I just realized I hadn't read your stuff in a while, and checked to see if you were still writing.  Since GR is my preferred way to read updates and I hate getting email updates, looks like I'm SOL.

When you click next / a page number on the bottom of a community page, it doesn't bring you back to the top of the list after it's changed it's content.  You have to scroll back up to see things in chronological order.

Maybe you should add the toolbar for navigating to front page/community section to the full blog posts pages.

Many times, I click on a blog post, go through it, then I want to go to the community section. But the toolbar isn't at the top of the post, as I expect it to be, and I can't do that, I have to go through the front page again.

Even going back to the home page of the blog might be confusing to people less used to browsing blogs. Sure, you can click the logo, but it's better to have a button that says "Home page" or "Front page" or something like that. Plus, if I am on a community section post, like this one, where will the logo take me? Front page or Community section? I have no idea right now, I have to try it. And this can be frustrating for first time users.

The idea, I guess, is that , for me, it's nice to have a unified navigation model through the whole site, with the same navigation menus on all pages.

Hey Ty,

After poking around, using almost all your features, etc. here's my  SETT feedback.  I'll do the 'feedback sandwich' so as not to hurt your feelings.

Top bun: 
I would use this for my blog if you would let me, not just because we've hung out and you're a good guy.

Meat: 
- Let me resize images in replies - as you can see from my reply to the 'lets make a books list' post, you can see that the two images I have are frickin huge.  I was able to resize them down when I first put them on there (they were put there via url, not uploaded) but when I actually posted them, they blew back up to the original size.
- Let me delete my posts, or at least my comments- I tried to when the huge pictures showed up and I couldn't.
- Another little thing about putting in images, and a larger point about the community side of SETT - when I wrote the 'post' about 'communication extremes' I wanted to break up the length with pictures.  It was inconvenient to have to scroll down to the bottom of everything to get to those buttons (could you just have them appear on the side once I decide I'm going to create a post, and then keep the menu of options floating in the middle of the page on the side so it would be easier to get at?).  Also, once I scrolled down the page, I wanted to try to avoid having to move the picture from the bottom of the post up to where I want it to be inserted into the post.  I put my cursor where I hoped it would end up being embedded and...it went in at the bottom of the post.  The greater point here is that if you want the community side feature of SETT to matter, it has to not feel like a message board where people just post threads of random crap - you want them to think & actually create and contribute, ideally.  You'd like for it all to be quality content and your voting things up and down feature helps with that.  But if people are going to think of their posts as actual posts, then try to give the community entries that would be considered 'posts' an experience like they were writing an actual post on their own blog.  Part of this experience includes keeping the formatting menu in view at all times, and I'm sure there's more to it - I'm not a UX pro - it just seems to be a key differentiating factor that's not captured in just 'make it easier for me to post pictures' kind of feedback.  One good example of you doing this is the "posting your masterpiece" message while you're waiting for it to load.
- embedding youtube videos - I did this on my comment about the community side of SETT - put in a mobileX video and it bled off the side of the comment column
- Hyperlinks - I put a bunch of URLs into my post, instead of making them hyperlinks...again, this comes back to the "make me feel like i'm writing an actual blog post" experience....because hopefully I am and it will end up on your front page because it's so freaking quality and I get exposure and you get great content at your blog that you didn't have to write - you know...one of the main differentiating factors of SETT  ;)

Bottom bun: 
I would use this (meaning, I would switch from my current platform - posterous btw).  Not sure you can give more of a compliment than that.
Also, I like that the bold, italics, & underline features can be activated through the standard keyboard shortcuts for them  (ctrl + i, ctrl + b, etc.)

Overall the platform is amazing, great job Tynan! I can't wait for you to release it to the public.

Here is my feedback/feature suggestions:

1) Consider putting the vote up/down arrows at the bottom of each post as well. I think it makes more sense to vote for a post once you've finished reading it, but I often forget to upvote good posts because after reading I don't scroll all the way to the top again.
2) SETT should automatically trim extra spaces at the beginning/end of the email on the login screen. I just spent some time trying to login unsuccessfully because there was an extra space at the end of my email.
3) Test SETT on the iPad. It is far more buggy on the iPad than on PC. In particular, the background image is not repeated vertically, so the background becomes white for the lower parts of the post. Also typing a response works very poorly, the cursor often jumps around and text is sometimes not displayed properly.

When I'm logged in you basically have my email address. There no need to ask in the [Like this?] Field for my email address to subscribe. 

An edit/delete comment feature would be nice.  I made a goofy typo in one of mine.