I throw away my change. Not all of it. Quarters of the lifeblood of laundry, and dimes have the best value to weight ratio, but I throw away all nickels and pennies.
If I'm at a store and I don't accidentally autpilot pocket my change, I'll leave the pennies and nickels on the counter. If I'm elsewhere I'll put them on a ledge or on top of a trash can where someone else will find them. But if I'm in my house and they're in my pocket, I just chuck them in the trash. I also do this for foreign currencies of similar denomination (Japanese one and five yen coins, for example).
Let's say that I use cash one hundred times per year. Half the time I'm buying something that rounds out to a dollar amount, and change doesn't factor into it. This is mostly street vendors which either don't charge tax or roll it into the price.
So fifty times per year I'm getting change. It would be interesting to think about the distribution of the "cents amount", but let's just assume that it's evenly distributed from 0 to 99 cents.
On average I will get back some amount of quarters and dimes, plus an average of five cents in nickels and pennies. I won't explain the math on that, but it's pretty intuitive if you think about it.
Assuming I throw all of those away, which I do, I'm losing five cents fifty times a year, costing me a total of $2.50.
What does that $2.50 buy me? Well, I never have to deal with nickels and pennies. That alone is worth $2.50 per year to me. Even better, it makes change way more usable for me. I don't have to dig through a change dish to find all of the quarters to do laundry-- all I have are quarters and dimes, and those are easy to separate. And if I have change in my pocket, as I always do in Japan, I'm far more likely to dig through it to pay for a purchase, because I know the coins are actually valuable.
Dimes are actually reasonable to toss as well. You get thirty-six dimes per every fifty transactions, meaning I'd only lose an additional $3.60 by completely throwing them out.
I think that a good dime policy would be to leave them in your car for parking meters, but to throw them away if you came across them in your house. You could keep them in your pocket throughout the day, but then throw away remainders at the end of the day.
Quarters, on the other hand, are directly useful, so I'll always keep them.
Your numbers may be different, so it may make sense for you to save more change than me. Maybe you deal with cash every single day.
What's interesting, I think, is to look at something that sounds barbaric and crazy, but is actually very logical. By giving up $2.50 per year, I get to make better use of quarters and reduce a tiny point of friction.
Photo is my poker chips at one point of the World Series of Poker this year.
If you read my latest book, Superhuman Social Skills, and liked it, PLEASE leave a review! Reviews have a huge impact on sales, especially when you have under 100 of them. I gave away the book for free this year hoping I'd get more reviews, but it didn't work so I may not do it next time.
This is why I simply use electronic forms of payment like credit cards and PayPal. When the store is cash-only, I use a middleman i.e. a friend and Venmo.
I knew a guy that was a trash man, and he would tell me that people would leave him jars of pennies beside the trash can. He was mentally slow, and he thought he was rich when he would get a jar of pennies.
I thought I was the only one who did this. I started doing this after traveling to Europe when I realized that all those low denomination coins were a waste of time.
I throw them out too! all but quarters... hadn't really thought through the practical reasons (yours make sense) I do it out of principle... they are ridiculous for society... so much productivity lost and germs spread passing these worthless things back and forth. I read somewhere that in the 1850s a half penny was the smallest denomination and it was worth like 500x more than a penny is now.
You're throwing away perfectly good zinc (under the copper coating in pennies). What I do couldn't be simpler: I smelt the zinc in the pennies using a propane torch and a spoon that I've clamped with locking pliers and a wooden clamp (use a powerful fan in a well ventilated area or you'll breath really bad fumes), removing the copper with a metal probe, then pouring the liquid zinc into a 1/2" pipe, and let it cool down. Then it's a simple bit of work to drill the blank I've created, and machine it to get a ring, hammering it over a socket bit to get the ring to the right size. A little bit of filing, sanding and buffing, and you have a beautiful zinc ring. If I have extra time, I'll forge the ring with the fires of Mount Doom to gain dominion over the free peoples of Middle Earth, but usually I just show my ring off by strutting down the street with it.
I'd been putting off writing a review but went ahead after reading this post. I think it's still too soon for most people who got a copy. Thanks for letting me have it for free; a review is the least I can do.
I went through a huge bag of change last night like I do every few months. It took 10 minutes at least and after counting hundreds of pennies and many nickels and dimes, I still had to use quarters to pay for a cheap meal. Not carrying all that crap in my pockets is the reason I'm going to only keep quarters from now on. Great idea.
I grabbed the new book but haven't gotten around to reading it yet. I will absolutely review it after I have. Hopefully that's the cause of the slow return on investment from your "promotion."
I picked up the book for free and liked it (thanks!), but it's hard to know the real value, and leave an honest review, without having at least a couple weeks to act on it. The real value of a self-help book is how much you change as a result of it's advice, not something like poetic language or a compelling story, so it takes time to evaluate.
I'll write a review once I've progressed through some more of the advice (and I currently expect it will be a positive review; I wrote a positive one for Superhuman by Habit), but it feels inauthentic to write before then. Too many Amazon reviews, particularly for books, are faked now. I know you aren't encouraging people to lie in their reviews, but there's still a certain dynamic at work in the free-for-reviews scheme. Just my thoughts.
It almost seems like more work to do this, since you have to pick out quarters and dimes every time you receive change. You're still dealing with pennies and nickels 50 times a year, even if you're dealing with them by identifying them and discarding them.
I just blindly pocket all change at the time of a transaction, and blindly dump it all in a change bowl at the end of the day. Two quick scoops, no sorting, ever. When the bowl is full (every couple years or so?) I bring it with me on a trip to the grocery store and let CoinStar turn it into an Amazon gift certificate, which means you pay no transaction fee. I skip the pain of ever sorting through change, and even the decision of whether or not I should hunt for change to make a purchase (I don't mind breaking a bill every time, because all the scraps are being efficiently converted back into spendable money).
Anyway, there are probably holes in this method too, but I just wanted to share what works for me!
I always help myself to the student discount when available. Sure, I don't actually go to school, but I still have my UT ID, and I'd argue that I learn more on a regular basis than most college students. Before today I'd never had any problem using my ID.
I'm sitting at a poker table at Foxwoods Casino in Connecticut. I haven't played in a while, and it's good to be back. I step away from the table to answer my phone. It's my mom and she wants to know where I am. I'm at the casino. She insists that I'm flying back to Austin at 7:30am the next morning. No, I was flying out on Sunday and planned on spending Saturday with the family. She checks, and she's actually right - my flight leaves in only seven hours.
We pile into the car and begin the two hour journey back to my grandparents' house where I'm staying. That gives me about 5 hours to sleep, pack, and leave the house.
Smart, by Shel Silverstein:
My dad gave me one dollar bill 'Cause I'm his smartest son, And I swapped it for two shiny quarters 'Cause two is more than one!
And then I took the quarters And traded them to Lou For three dimes -- I guess he didn't know That three is more than two!
Just then, along came old blind Bates And just 'cause he can't see He gave me four nickels for my three dimes, And four is more than three!
And then I took the nickels to Hiram Coombs Down at the seed-feed store, And the fool gave me five pennies for them, And five is more than four!